In this last and final part of this study, Al-Banna wraps up his essay by addressing contemporary arguments against the obligation for violent jihad. In a passage that could have been written by any online jihadi today, Al-Banna dismisses the "greater" vs" lesser" jihad argument. In a fascinating reversal of tactics, it's Brotherhood members themselves who use the "greater vs lesser" argument to deflect criticism from non-Muslims.
Mercy in the Islamic Jihad
Since the goal of the Islamic jihad was the noblest of goals, the means employed were also the most excellent of means. For God has forbidden aggression. He, the Almighty, has said: "Do not instigate hostilities, for God loves not those who instigate hostilities" [Q.2:190], and He commanded that justice be observed, even toward the enemy and the adversary. He, the Almighty, has said: "Let not hatred of a people coerce you into treating them unjustly. Be just: it is closer to piety" [Q.5:2]. He has guided the Muslims to act with the utmost mercy.
For when they fight, they do not instigate hostilities, nor do they behave licentiously, nor do they mutilate, nor do they steal or plunder property, nor do they commit rape, nor do they indulge in wanton destruction. In their warfare they are the best of fighters, just as in peace they are the most excellent of peacemakers.
On the authority of Burayda (May God be pleased with him!), who said: "Whenever the Apostle of God (May God bless and save him!) appointed a commander over an army or a band of raiders, he charged him to behave with piety toward God Almighty in his inward self, and with benevolent care for the Muslims who were with him." Then he [i.e., the Prophet] said: "Campaign in the name of God in God's way! Fight those who disbelieve in God: campaign, but do not indulge in excesses, do not act treacherously, do not mutilate, and do not slay children." Transmitted by Muslim.
On the authority of Abu Hurayra (May God be pleased with him!), who said: "The Apostle of God (May God bless and save him!) said: 'When one of you fights, let him avoid [striking] the face.'" Published by the Two Shaykhs.
On the authority of Ibn Mas'ud (May God be pleased with him!), who said: "The Apostle of God (May God bless and save him!) said: 'The most continent of mankind are the fighters of the People of the Faith.'" Published by Abu Da'ud.
On the authority of "Abd Allah b. Yazid al-Ansari (May God be pleased with him!), who said: "The Apostle of God (May God bless and save him!) forbade plundering and mutilation." Published by Al-Bukhari.
So also it is forbidden to slay women, children, and old men, and to despatch the wounded, or to disturb monks and hermits, and the peaceful who offer no resistance. Just contrast this mercy with the murderous warfare of the civilized peoples and their disgusting atrocities! And what is their international law alongside this all-embracing, divinely ordained justice?
My God, instruct the Muslims in their religion, and save the world from these injustices with the enlightenment of Islam!
Supplements to Jihad
The belief is widespread among many Muslims that fighting the enemy is the lesser jihad, and that there is a greater jihad, the jihad of the spirit. Many of them invoke as proof of this the following narration [athar]: "'We have returned from the lesser jihad to embark on the greater jihad.’ They said: ‘What is the greater jihad?’ He said: 'The jihad of the heart, or the jihad of the spirit.'"
Some of them try, by recourse to this, to divert people from the importance of fighting, preparing for combat, and resolving to undertake it and embark on God's way. This narration is not really a sound Tradition: the Prince of Believers in matters of Tradition, Al-Hafiz b. Hajar, said in the Tasdid al-Qaws; "It is well-known and often repeated, and was a saying of Ibrahim b. Abla."
Al-'Iraqi said in the Takhrij Ahadith al-Ahya: "Al-Bayhaqi transmitted it with a weak chain ot guarantors on the authority of Jabir, and Al-Khatib transmitted it in his history on the authority of Jabir." Nevertheless, even if it were a sound Tradition, it would never warrant abandoning jihad, or preparing for it in order to rescue the territories of the Muslims and repel the attacks of unbelievers. Its meaning is simply that it is necessary to struggle with the spirit so that it may be sincerely devoted to God in every one of its acts. So let it be known.
Other supplementary matters concerned with jihad are the following: to command the good and forbid the evil. It is said in the Traditions: "One of the loftiest forms of jihad is to utter a word of truth in the presence of a tyrannical ruler.'
But nothing in them confers on their advocate, the supreme martyrdom and the reward of the strivers in jihad, unless he slays or is slain in the way of God.
Epilogue
Brethren! God gives the umma that is skilled in the practice of death and that knows how to die a noble death, an exalted life in this world and eternal felicity in the next. What is the fantasy that has reduced us to loving this world and hating death? If you gird yourselves for a lofty deed and yearn for death, life shall be given to you.
Know then that death is inevitable, and that it can only happen once. If you suffer it in the way of God, it will be to your profit in this world, and your reward in the next. Nothing shall touch you but what God has decreed for you: ponder well what God, the Blessed, the Almighty, has said: "Then after the affliction. He sent down security upon you, as slumber which overcame a party of you; while a party whom concern for themselves had preoccupied were surmising untruth of God, the surmise of pagandom, saying: ‘Do we have any share in this matter at all?' Say: ‘The matter is God's entirely.' They hide within themselves what they do not reveal to thee, and say: ‘if we had had any share in this matter, we would not have been slain here.' Say: ‘Even if you had been in your houses, those for whom slaughter had been decreed would have gone forth to their resting-places -and so that God might test what is in your breasts and examine what is in your hearts. God knows what lies within your breasts'" [Q.3:154].
If you strive for an honorable death, you will win to perfect happiness. May God bestow upon us and upon you the honor of martyrdom in His way!